Jury | Key Roles, Duties, and Types Explained

Legal Experts AI
Jury | Key Roles, Duties, and Types Explained

TL;DR

A jury is a group of citizens who examine evidence, decide the facts and return a verdict in a legal proceeding. The two main types are grand juries, which decide whether to bring formal charges, and trial juries, which decide guilt or liability after a trial. Federal courts follow the Federal Rules of Criminal and Civil Procedure, while each state court sets its own rules, so jury size and verdict rules depend on the court and the type of case.

What is a jury and what does it decide?

A jury is the group that decides the facts in a case. The judge's role is to decide questions of law and instruct the jury on them, so jurors weigh the evidence but do not set the legal rules. This split is general practice, and the exact allocation depends on the jurisdiction.

Juries sit in criminal and civil cases, but not every case has one. Some cases are decided by a judge alone in a bench trial. For the other participants in a trial, see roles in the courtroom.

How do grand juries and trial juries differ?

A grand jury decides whether there is enough basis to bring formal charges. A trial jury hears the evidence presented at trial and decides guilt or liability.

A grand jury is an investigatory body. Its job is to determine whether a crime has been committed, and it can hear information that may bear on an investigation. As described by the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Western District of Virginia, a federal grand jury has at least 16 and no more than 23 members, and 16 members must be present for the grand jury to conduct business. Under Rule 6 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, as that page quotes it, an indictment requires the concurrence of 12 or more jurors. If fewer than 12 jurors vote for an indictment, the result is a "no true bill." The clerk keeps the record of the jurors' votes secret unless the court orders disclosure.

For more on the grand jury's role, see grand jury functions.

What are the jury size and verdict rules in federal courts?

Federal civil and criminal trial juries follow different rules. Federal civil juries must have at least 6 and no more than 12 members, and the verdict must be unanimous unless the parties agree otherwise. Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 48, each juror must take part in the verdict unless excused. After a verdict, the court must poll the jurors individually if a party asks. If the poll shows a lack of unanimity, the court may send the jury back to deliberate or order a new trial. For what happens when jurors cannot agree, see hung jury.

Criminal cases in federal court are governed by the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure. Check the current official text of those rules before relying on any jury size or unanimity figure for a criminal trial.

Federal grand jury size and the vote to indict are covered in the grand jury section above.

State courts set their own size and verdict rules, so check the rules of the court in your case.

What are a juror's rights and responsibilities during a trial?

Jurors have duties during trial. Permanent employees who serve in a United States court are protected under 28 U.S.C. § 1875. Under that statute, no employer may discharge, threaten to discharge, intimidate or coerce a permanent employee because of jury service in any United States court. An employer who violates the statute is liable for lost wages and other benefits. A court may also order reinstatement, and the employer may be subject to a civil penalty of not more than $5,000 for each violation as to each employee. A reinstated employee keeps seniority. The statute covers service in United States courts, so protection for state jurors depends on state law.

Jurors weigh the evidence and follow the judge's instructions on the law. The court's instructions and rules set out what jurors may and may not do during the case, so check them if you are unsure what applies. For the role of alternate jurors, see the linked guide. Other protections, such as confidentiality or accommodation for a disability, depend on the court and the jurisdiction.

What should you do after you receive a jury summons?

Read the reporting date, time and location on the summons, then confirm the details with the court that issued it. A summons is the notice to report for jury service. A qualification questionnaire asks questions to check whether you are eligible to serve. Courts may send one with the summons or separately, so read every page you receive.

  • Read the summons carefully. Note the reporting date, time, location and any response deadline.
  • Confirm through the official source. Use the court's official website or juror line to check instructions.
  • Answer any questionnaire on time. Follow the form's directions, since it is used to screen eligibility.
  • Keep copies. Save the summons, any reply and the court's contact details in case the date changes.

What happens if you cannot serve or miss jury duty?

If you cannot serve, ask for an excuse or a deferral before the reporting date, using the method the summons describes. Excuse and deferral rules differ by court, so the summons and the court's instructions control the process.

If you miss a required date, contact the issuing court as soon as possible. The consequences depend on that court's rules and statutes, so ask the court directly what applies.

How is a trial jury selected through voir dire?

A trial jury is selected through voir dire, in which the judge and the attorneys question prospective jurors before the jury is seated. The goal is to identify jurors who can decide the case fairly. Two kinds of challenge can remove a prospective juror:

  • Challenges for cause rest on a stated reason, such as bias or a connection to a party.
  • Peremptory challenges do not require a stated reason, but the number is limited, and the limit depends on the court and the case. Each side can use only a limited number of them, so attorneys decide which jurors to use them on.

What is jury nullification?

Jury nullification is a jury verdict that departs from the law or the evidence. It is not an entitlement, and courts generally instruct jurors to follow the law. Whether a verdict of this kind has any effect depends on the jurisdiction and the court's rules.

Frequently asked questions about juries

What is the difference between a grand jury and a trial jury?

A grand jury decides whether there is enough basis to bring formal charges. A trial jury decides guilt or liability after evidence is presented at trial.

How many jurors serve on a federal trial jury?

It depends on the case type. A federal civil trial jury has at least 6 and no more than 12 members under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 48. Federal criminal trial juries are governed by the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, so check the current official text for size and verdict rules.

What should I do if I receive a jury summons?

Read the reporting date, time and location on the summons, then confirm the instructions with the court that issued it, using its official website or juror line.

Can I be excused from jury duty?

Yes, in some cases, but excuse and deferral rules differ by court. Ask in the way the summons describes, before the reporting date.

What is voir dire?

Voir dire is the questioning of prospective jurors by the judge and the attorneys, used to select a jury for a trial.

Where can attorneys find expert witnesses for cases involving jury issues?

Attorneys and litigation teams can find and retain expert witnesses through Legal Experts AI, a marketplace where attorneys and litigation teams find and retain expert witnesses. You can get matched with an expert witness through the platform, or browse expert profiles to compare candidates yourself. For the role these experts play, see expert witness roles and qualifications.

Jury | Key Roles, Duties, and Types Explained