Quick answer
A hung jury, also called a deadlocked jury, is a jury that cannot reach the verdict the law requires. In federal criminal cases, the verdict must be unanimous. In federal civil cases, it must be unanimous unless the parties agree otherwise.
A hung jury does not decide the case by itself. The judge may declare a mistrial, and the case may then be retried, dismissed or settled, depending on the jurisdiction, the case type and the decisions of the prosecutor or the parties. State courts set their own verdict rules, so check the rule for the state where the case is pending. This page is general information, not legal advice.
What is a hung jury?
A hung jury is a jury that cannot agree on the verdict the applicable rule requires. Under Rule 31(a) of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, "The verdict must be unanimous," and the jury returns it to a judge in open court. In federal civil cases, Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 48(b) says, "Unless the parties stipulate otherwise, the verdict must be unanimous."
A deadlock happens when the jury cannot meet that requirement. For the role of jurors, see jury roles and duties.
How is a hung jury different from a mistrial?
A hung jury is one reason a judge may declare a mistrial, but a mistrial can have other causes. Under Rule 31(b)(3), "the court may declare a mistrial" on counts the jury cannot agree on.
The Supreme Court's opinion in Richardson v. United States notes that the Court has also reviewed mistrials "granted for reasons other than the inability of the jury to agree," including mistrials granted on a prosecutor's or a defendant's motion. The rule that a deadlock permits a mistrial goes back to United States v. Perez (1824), discussed below.
How do judges respond to a deadlocked jury?
Before a mistrial, judges may take the steps below, and their limits depend on the jurisdiction. In federal criminal cases, Rule 26.3 requires the court to hear from the parties first. Before ordering a mistrial, the court must give each defendant and the government "an opportunity to comment on the propriety of the order, to state whether that party consents or objects, and to suggest alternatives."
Judges may also give jurors a supplemental instruction, which courts often call an Allen charge. In Allen v. United States (1896), the Supreme Court reviewed an instruction given after the jury returned to court for further instructions. It told jurors to listen to one another with a disposition to be convinced, and it asked dissenting jurors to consider whether their doubt was reasonable.
Whether a particular instruction is proper, and what limits apply, depends on the jurisdiction and its rules.
What can happen to the case after a mistrial for deadlock?
The case does not end automatically. In Richardson, the Court said that "a retrial following a 'hung jury' does not violate the Double Jeopardy Clause."
In federal criminal cases, Rule 31(b)(3) provides that "The government may retry any defendant on any count on which the jury could not agree." The rule permits retrial but does not say whether the government should retry or dismiss. For the prosecutor's role, see the role of a prosecuting attorney. A negotiated plea is another path some criminal cases take.
In civil cases, the path depends on the court and the rules that apply. The parties may settle, or further proceedings may follow.
How do hung juries differ in criminal and civil cases?
The main difference is the verdict rule and who controls the next step. In federal criminal cases, the verdict must be unanimous under Rule 31(a), and the government may retry counts the jury could not agree on under Rule 31(b)(3). In federal civil cases, the verdict must be unanimous under Rule 48(b) unless the parties stipulate otherwise, and state civil rules can differ.
For the wider criminal process, see criminal law basics.
How do state rules differ from federal rules?
State verdict rules are set by each state's statutes and court rules, and the federal rules below apply only in federal courts.
| Jurisdiction | Criminal verdict rule | Civil verdict rule | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Federal courts | Must be unanimous | Must be unanimous unless the parties stipulate otherwise | Fed. R. Crim. P. 31(a); Fed. R. Civ. P. 48(b) |
For a state case, check that state's statute or court rule before relying on any verdict rule.
Which cases shaped the rules on hung juries?
Three Supreme Court decisions address hung juries directly: Perez (1824), Allen (1896) and Richardson (1984).
- United States v. Perez (1824). As Richardson describes it, Justice Story treated a failure to agree as "manifest necessity," which let a trial judge end the first trial and retry the defendant, because "the ends of public justice would otherwise be defeated."
- Allen v. United States (1896). The Court reviewed the supplemental instruction described above, the kind of instruction now often called an Allen charge.
- Richardson v. United States (1984). The Court held that a retrial after a hung jury does not violate the Double Jeopardy Clause.
When should a party consult a licensed attorney?
Yes. Decisions about retrial, dismissal, plea or settlement depend on the facts of the case and the rules of the court where it is pending. A licensed attorney in that jurisdiction can apply those rules to the facts.
Frequently asked questions
Is a hung jury the same as an acquittal?
No. A hung jury produces no verdict, and an acquittal is a verdict.
Can a case be retried after a hung jury?
Yes. In Richardson, the Court said a retrial after a hung jury does not violate the Double Jeopardy Clause. In federal criminal cases, the government may retry the counts the jury could not agree on under Rule 31(b)(3).
Does a hung jury mean the case is over?
No. The trial ends without a verdict, and the case can continue through retrial, dismissal or settlement, depending on the jurisdiction.
What is an Allen charge?
An Allen charge is the name courts often use for a supplemental instruction that asks jurors to keep deliberating, as reviewed in Allen v. United States (1896).
Does a civil jury have to reach a unanimous verdict?
In federal court, yes, unless the parties stipulate otherwise under Rule 48(b). State civil rules vary.
Is a mistrial for deadlock the same as a dismissal?
No. A mistrial ends that trial, and under Rule 31(b)(3) the government may retry the counts. A dismissal ends the case instead.
Should I consult an attorney after a hung jury?
Yes. A licensed attorney in the relevant jurisdiction can advise on retrial, dismissal, plea or settlement decisions.
Does Legal Experts AI give legal advice?
No. Legal Experts AI provides general educational information on U.S. legal matters. It is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice.
Where can litigation teams find expert witnesses for a retrial?
Litigation teams can find and retain expert witnesses through Legal Experts AI, a marketplace where attorneys and litigation teams find and retain expert witnesses. Start with Get Matched, or browse expert profiles to review candidates yourself.




