Quick answer
A grand jury is a group of citizens that decides whether the evidence a prosecutor presents is enough to charge a person with a crime by indictment. It does not decide guilt or innocence; a trial jury does that. Federal felonies generally must be prosecuted by indictment. State grand jury rules differ from the federal rules described below.
What does a grand jury decide?
A grand jury decides whether to return an indictment, the formal charge that lets a felony case move forward. Jurors apply probable cause: a reasonable belief, based on facts, that a crime was committed and the suspect committed it. That standard is lower than the proof beyond a reasonable doubt needed to convict at trial.
Does a grand jury decide guilt or innocence?
No. Guilt or innocence is decided at trial.
What does a "true bill" mean?
A true bill is the grand jury's decision that the evidence supports an indictment. When the jurors do not agree to indict, they return no true bill.
How is a grand jury different from a trial jury?
A grand jury decides whether to indict, while a trial jury decides the case on the evidence heard at trial.
| Grand jury | Trial jury | |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Decide whether to indict | Decide the case on the evidence heard at trial |
| Decision | True bill (indictment) or no true bill | Verdict |
| Vote needed | Set by Rule 6(f), which governs returning indictments | Set by the trial verdict rule; the threshold is not stated here |
| Secrecy | Deliberations and votes are secret | Open to the public under a First Amendment right to attend criminal trials |
| Who presents evidence | Prosecutors, usually with evidence gathered by federal agents | Prosecutors and defense attorneys |
For jury types and duties, see jury types and duties. For what happens when a trial jury cannot agree, see what happens when a trial jury cannot agree.
What vote does a federal grand jury need to return an indictment?
Rule 6(f) governs the return of federal indictments, so the vote needed is set by its current text. Check that text before relying on any number.
How many jurors typically compose a grand jury?
Federal member counts are governed by the federal rules, so check the current text of Rule 6 for the figure. The advisory note to Rule 6(a) addresses how many grand juries a court may summon, not how many members each one has. It describes the court's "full discretion as to the number of grand juries to be summoned and as to the times when they should be convened." State member counts depend on state law.
How many members does a federal grand jury have?
Federal grand jury size is set by the federal rules, so check the current text of Rule 6 for the figure.
When is a grand jury used in legal proceedings?
In federal cases, Rule 7(a)(1) requires that a felony be prosecuted by indictment, though criminal contempt is excepted. In federal prosecutions, the Fifth Amendment, as quoted in the advisory note to Rule 7(a), says no person shall be held to answer for a capital, or otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a grand jury. The same note says any offense punishable by imprisonment for a term of over one year is an infamous crime.
In federal cases, Rule 7(b) provides that an offense punishable by more than one year may be prosecuted by information if the defendant, in open court and after being advised of the charge and of the defendant's rights, waives prosecution by indictment.
Do all states use grand juries?
Not necessarily. Whether a state uses a grand jury for felony charges depends on that state's law, so check the state's criminal procedure statute or court rules.
How does a grand jury proceeding work, from presentation to vote?
- Present the evidence. In federal cases, agents gather the information and prosecutors present it to the grand jury.
- Ask questions where the procedure allows. Whether jurors may question witnesses or investigate on their own depends on the jurisdiction.
- Deliberate in private. The advisory note to Rule 6(e) describes the discussion as secret.
- Vote on the charge. Jurors return a true bill (indictment) or no true bill.
Who may attend, and what secrecy rules apply?
Government attorneys may be present while evidence is presented, but deliberations and votes stay secret. Rule 6(d) sets who else may attend, so check its current text.
The advisory note to Rule 6(e) says the rule continues the traditional practice of secrecy for grand jury members, except when the court permits disclosure. Government personnel who receive grand jury material may use it only to help enforce federal criminal law. A court may direct disclosure in connection with a judicial proceeding. A defendant may request disclosure by showing that grounds may exist to dismiss the indictment because of matters before the grand jury.
Are grand jury proceedings open to the public?
Generally no. The advisory note to Rule 6(e) says the rule continues the traditional practice of secrecy on the part of grand jury members, except when the court permits disclosure.
Can grand jury witnesses discuss their testimony?
The secrecy duty in the advisory note applies to grand jury members, so the answer for witnesses depends on the current text of Rule 6(e) and any court order.
Do grand juries check prosecutors, and what are the main criticisms?
Yes, in a limited way. In federal cases, a grand jury reviews a felony charge before it proceeds. The evidence reaches the jurors through prosecutors, who present evidence that federal agents gathered, and the probable-cause standard is low.
The advisory note to Rule 6(e) quotes a principle on defense access to grand jury testimony: "in our adversary system for determining guilt or innocence, it is rarely justifiable for the prosecution to have exclusive access to a storehouse of relevant facts." How courts review a grand jury's decision depends on the jurisdiction, so check current case law for any specific challenge.
Where can attorneys verify current grand jury rules and find expert support?
Verify federal grand jury rules in Rule 6 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure on the official federal rules page, and state rules in the state's criminal procedure statute or court rules. Legal Experts AI is a marketplace where attorneys and litigation teams find and retain expert witnesses. Attorneys who need an expert witness can start with Get Matched, or browse expert profiles first.




