TL;DR
A bench trial is a trial in which a judge, without a jury, decides both the facts and the law. It is used when no jury is required or when the parties waive one, and unlike a jury trial, the judge alone finds the facts. In federal criminal cases, a defendant can waive a jury only in writing, with the government's consent and the court's approval (Fed. R. Crim. P. 23(a)). In federal civil cases, the parties can stipulate to a nonjury trial (Fed. R. Civ. P. 39(a)(1)), and the judge must then state findings of fact and conclusions of law (Rule 52(a)(1)).
What Is a Bench Trial?
A bench trial is a trial in which the judge is the sole fact-finder and the sole legal decision-maker, without a jury. It is used when no jury is required or when the parties waive one. Some searches use the phrase "bench litigation"; this page uses "bench trial." For the term's wider meaning, see the bench meaning in law guide.
How Does a Bench Trial Differ From a Jury Trial?
A judge alone finds the facts in a bench trial, while a jury finds them in a jury trial.
| Point | Bench trial | Jury trial |
|---|---|---|
| Who finds the facts | The judge | The jury |
| Who applies the law | The judge | The judge, who instructs the jury on the law |
| Jury selection and instructions | Absent | Present |
| Who must state findings | The judge: required in federal civil nonjury cases (Rule 52(a)(1)); in federal criminal cases, on a party's request before the verdict (Rule 23(c)) | Not required; the verdict decides the case |
| Appellate record | Findings and conclusions show the judge's reasoning | Verdict and trial record |
What Are the Advantages and Disadvantages of a Bench Trial?
The main advantages are the judge's legal experience, the absence of jury-related emotional influence, and fewer steps, such as jury selection and instructions. The main disadvantages are the risk that a judge's preconceptions affect the outcome and the loss of a jury's community perspective. These are general considerations, not measured results.
Who Must Agree to a Bench Trial in a Criminal Case?
In Singer v. United States, 380 U.S. 24 (1965), the Supreme Court quoted the federal rule as requiring a written waiver "with the approval of the court and the consent of the government."
Federal criminal cases
Under Rule 23(a), as quoted in Singer, a federal criminal waiver must be written, with the government's consent and the court's approval. Singer also notes that states have adopted different waiver procedures.
Can Parties Waive a Jury in a Civil Case?
Yes. Under Rule 39(a), a jury trial that has been demanded must be tried by jury unless the parties stipulate to a nonjury trial, or the court finds there is no federal right to a jury on those issues. The stipulation must be filed or made on the record (Rule 39(a)(1)). State civil rules differ and are not covered here.
When Must a Judge State Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law?
Rule 52(a)(1) says that in an action tried on the facts without a jury, the court "must find the facts specially and state its conclusions of law separately." Under Rule 23(c), a criminal bench trial requires specific findings when a party requests them before the finding of guilty or not guilty, stated in open court or in a written decision.
How Is a Bench Trial Requested, Step by Step?
- Confirm whether a jury right applies. In a civil case, Rule 39(a) governs; in a criminal case, the waiver rule in Rule 23(a) governs.
- File the waiver or stipulation. Criminal waivers must be written; civil stipulations must be filed or made on the record (Rule 39(a)(1)).
- Obtain consent and approval in criminal cases.
- Request findings where the rule allows. In a criminal bench trial, ask before the verdict (Rule 23(c)). In a federal civil nonjury case, findings are required under Rule 52(a)(1) without a request.
For broader preparation, see trial preparation steps.
How Do Appeals Work After a Bench Trial?
Under Rule 52(a)(6), findings of fact "must not be set aside unless clearly erroneous," and the reviewing court must give due regard to the trial court's opportunity to judge witness credibility. The rule's text covers findings of fact only; the standard for conclusions of law depends on the governing law and the appellate court's rules.
How Did Singer v. United States Shape Criminal Bench Trials?
Singer upheld the validity of the federal rule requiring court approval and government consent for a criminal jury waiver. The Court did not decide whether compelling reasons could change the result, because the petitioner offered only time savings.
Common Questions About Bench Trials Answered
Who Decides the Verdict in a Bench Trial?
The judge decides both the facts and the legal questions, without a jury.
Can a Criminal Defendant Waive a Jury Trial Without the Prosecutor Agreeing?
No. Under the rule quoted in Singer, the government's consent is required as well as the court's approval.
Must a Judge Write Findings in a Bench Trial?
It depends on the case type: federal civil nonjury cases require findings under Rule 52(a)(1), while federal criminal bench trials require specific findings when a party requests them under Rule 23(c).
Do the Rules of Evidence Apply in a Bench Trial?
Generally yes in federal court. Under Fed. R. Evid. 1101(b), the rules apply in civil and criminal cases, subject to the exceptions in Rule 1101(d) and (e). The text does not single out bench trials, so how the rules apply in a particular case is a question for the court. For pretrial evidence disputes, see motions in limine.
Do Expert Witnesses Testify in a Bench Trial?
Yes. Under Fed. R. Evid. 702, a qualified expert may testify when the proponent shows the court that it is more likely than not that the testimony will help the trier of fact, rests on sufficient facts or data, uses reliable methods, and reliably applies them to the case.
Legal Experts AI is a marketplace where attorneys and litigation teams find and retain expert witnesses, with expert profile search and AI-assisted expert matching. Before choosing, compare roles in trial expert versus consulting expert. Get matched with an expert witness or browse expert profiles.




