Quick answer
An alternate juror is a juror seated to replace a regular juror who cannot continue. Alternates sit through the trial, but they deliberate only if they replace a seated juror. In federal criminal trials, Rule 24(c) of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure governs alternates, and state rules vary.
Under that rule, a federal court may seat up to six alternates. A retained alternate may not discuss the case until they replace a juror or are discharged. If an alternate replaces a juror after deliberations have begun, the court must instruct the jury to begin its deliberations anew.
What is an alternate juror?
An alternate juror is a juror selected with the jury to take the place of a juror who becomes unable to serve or is disqualified. "Alternate jury" is a common variant of the same term and refers to these alternate seats, not a second jury. Under Rule 24(c)(2)(A), alternates have the same qualifications as other jurors and are selected and sworn in the same manner. Their role differs only in that they join deliberations when a seated juror cannot continue.
How does a court select alternate jurors?
A federal criminal court may impanel up to six alternates, and it sets the number within that limit. The steps are:
- Selection. Alternates must have the same qualifications and are selected and sworn in the same manner as other jurors (Rule 24(c)(2)(A)).
- Order. Alternates replace jurors in the order in which they were selected (Rule 24(c)(2)(B)).
- Challenges. Each side gets extra peremptory challenges that may be used only to remove alternates: one for one or two alternates, two for three or four, and three for five or six (Rule 24(c)(4)).
What do alternate jurors do during the trial?
Alternates sit through the trial so they are ready to replace a seated juror, and they follow the court's instructions while they wait. Two rules limit their role:
- Authority after replacing a juror. An alternate who replaces a juror has the same authority as the other jurors (Rule 24(c)(2)(B)).
- No discussion. If the court keeps alternates after the jury retires to deliberate, a retained alternate may not discuss the case with anyone until they replace a juror or are discharged (Rule 24(c)(3)).
How does a juror learn they are an alternate?
A court designates alternates when it selects the jury, and alternates replace jurors in the order they were selected (Rule 24(c)(2)(A) and (B)). Once designated, an alternate is expected to follow the court's instructions. If the court retains alternates after the jury retires, a retained alternate may not discuss the case until they replace a juror or are discharged (Rule 24(c)(3)). Rule 24(c) does not describe how a court tells a juror of that designation, so the practice is set by each court and varies. Check the court's own rules for the notice and instructions it gives.
What happens if a juror is replaced after deliberations begin?
Under Rule 24(c)(3) of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, "If an alternate replaces a juror after deliberations have begun, the court must instruct the jury to begin its deliberations anew." That rule covers federal criminal trials. For state courts, check the state's rules, since they differ.
How do federal civil trials handle alternate jurors?
Rule 47 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure does not address alternate jurors, so the criminal Rule 24(c) should not be assumed to apply to civil trials. Rule 47 covers examining jurors, peremptory challenges and excusing jurors. It provides that "the court may excuse a juror for good cause" during trial or deliberation (Rule 47(c)). Whether a civil court seats alternates, and how it replaces an excused juror, depends on the court's practice and rules beyond Rule 47.
How does Montana law handle alternate jurors?
Montana Code Annotated 3-15-402 covers how the trial jury list is compiled. Its text does not address how alternate jurors are seated, used during deliberation or replaced. Section 3-15-402 has the secretary of state compile a list of persons qualified to serve as trial jurors from registered active electors, and it has the office of court administrator combine that list so no name appears on the combined list more than once. For seating, use during deliberation and replacement of alternates in Montana, check the current Montana Code Annotated and the rules of the court handling the case.
Which official sources control alternate juror rules?
The rule text controls, and this article only summarizes it. Check these sources:
- Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, Rule 24, for federal criminal trials.
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 47, for federal civil trials.
- Montana Code Annotated, for Montana law.
- State codes and local court rules, for every other state.
Frequently asked questions
Alternates deliberate only if they replace a seated juror, and state rules differ.
Can alternate jurors take part in deliberations?
Not unless they replace a seated juror. Under Rule 24(c)(3) of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, a retained alternate may not discuss the case until they replace a juror or are discharged.
Do alternate juror rules vary by state?
Yes. Rhode Island's civil jury statute, for example, lets a court call one or two additional jurors, known as alternate jurors, when a civil jury trial is likely to be protracted (R.I. Gen. Laws § 9-10-13). Other states set their own rules, so check the code and local rules of the state where the case is heard.
How can attorneys find expert witnesses?
Legal Experts AI is a marketplace where attorneys and litigation teams find and retain expert witnesses. You can get matched with an expert witness by AI, or browse expert profiles to compare professionals yourself.




