Judge | Roles, Types, and How to Become One

Legal Experts AI
Judge | Roles, Types, and How to Become One

Quick answer

The judge role centers on presiding over court proceedings, applying the law to resolve disputes, ruling on motions and questions of law, and, in jury trials, instructing the jury. A judge's title, jurisdiction and selection method depend on the court. Federal judges are nominated by the President and confirmed by the Senate, while state and county judges are selected under each state's own rules.

  • Duties: Judges run hearings and trials, rule on motions, and decide whether evidence, including expert testimony, can be heard.
  • Court types: Federal judges include Article III judges and magistrate judges. State and county judges work under state law.
  • Selection and qualifications: Federal judges are nominated and confirmed. Qualifications are set by the specific court or state, so check the rule for the position you are researching.

What do judges do in court?

Judges preside over hearings and trials and rule on the motions and legal questions that move a case forward. In a jury trial, the judge instructs the jury on the law it must apply. They also decide whether evidence, including expert testimony, can be presented.

What are Article III judges?

Article III judges are federal judges whose tenure the Constitution sets. Article III, Section 1 says federal judges "shall hold their Offices during good Behaviour" (U.S. Constitution, Article III, Section 1). The annotated Constitution, good behavior clause from the Legal Information Institute explains that this standard "ensures that federal judges hold their seats for life, rather than set terms or at the will of a superior." Article III, Section 1 creates the Supreme Court and allows Congress to establish inferior courts.

What do magistrate and bankruptcy judges do?

Magistrate judges help federal district judges with pretrial and procedural work, and bankruptcy judges hear bankruptcy cases.

What does a magistrate judge do?

When a district judge designates them, magistrate judges can decide many pretrial matters and hold hearings. With the parties' consent, they can also decide a civil case. Under 28 U.S.C. § 636, a magistrate judge may:

  • administer oaths, issue orders on release or detention pending trial, and take acknowledgments, affidavits and depositions;
  • when a district judge designates them, hear and determine most pretrial matters, except motions such as summary judgment and motions to suppress evidence in a criminal case;
  • when designated, conduct evidentiary hearings and submit proposed findings and recommendations to a district judge;
  • when specially designated by the district court and with the parties' consent, conduct proceedings in a civil case and order entry of judgment.

What do bankruptcy judges do?

Bankruptcy judges hear bankruptcy cases.

Is a county judge a court judge in every state?

No, not necessarily. A county judge's title and duties depend on the state, and the same title can carry different responsibilities from one state to another. Check the rules of the state whose court system you are researching.

How are judges selected?

Federal judges are nominated by the President and confirmed by the Senate. Under Article II, Section 2, the President nominates and, with the Senate's "Advice and Consent," appoints "Judges of the supreme Court" and other federal officers. The annotated Constitution notes that Senate consideration of Supreme Court nominees can involve political considerations, a nominee's judicial philosophy and fitness for the bench.

State judges are chosen under each state's own rules, and those methods differ. For how chief judges are chosen and what they do, read chief judge roles and selection.

What qualifications do judges need?

Qualifications depend on the specific court or state, and the rule for that position sets them. For magistrate judges, 28 U.S.C. § 636 makes part-time civil jurisdiction with the parties' consent depend on meeting the bar membership requirements in section 631(b)(1).

Judicial clerkships are one general career path.

Where can you find current pay and job outlook for judges?

Official pay and outlook information for judges is linked below; check the date on any figure before you use it. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics publishes an Occupational Outlook Handbook entry for judges and magistrates. Federal judicial salary information is available on the U.S. federal courts website.

How do judges handle expert testimony?

Under Federal Rule of Evidence 702, a qualified expert may testify if the proponent demonstrates to the court that it is more likely than not that four things are true: the expert's specialized knowledge will help the trier of fact, the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data, it is the product of reliable principles and methods, and the opinion reflects a reliable application of those methods to the facts. In federal court, the judge decides whether that showing has been made, so the judge rules on whether the testimony is admissible.

Attorneys and litigation teams retain expert witnesses; in federal court, the judge rules on whether their testimony can be heard. For the expert's role, read the expert witness role in court. For the lawyer's side, see the attorney's legal role.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between an Article III judge and an Article I judge?

Article III judges hold office during good behavior under Article III, Section 1 of the Constitution. Congress can also establish inferior courts under that section.

Do federal judges need a law degree?

It depends on the court or position, so the rule that governs it decides the answer. Check the rule for the specific court or position before relying on any requirement.

What does a magistrate judge do?

When a district judge designates them, a magistrate judge can hear and decide many pretrial matters and, with the parties' consent, decide a civil case. The full list of powers is in 28 U.S.C. § 636.

Is a county judge a court judge in every state?

No, not necessarily. The title and duties depend on the state, so check that state's court system.

How are federal judges appointed?

Federal judges are nominated by the President and confirmed by the Senate. According to the annotated Constitution, Senate consideration of Supreme Court nominees can involve political considerations.

Does a judge decide whether an expert witness can testify?

In federal court, yes. Federal Rule of Evidence 702 requires the proponent to demonstrate to the court that the testimony meets the rule's requirements.

How can attorneys find expert witnesses?

Attorneys and litigation teams can find and retain expert witnesses through Legal Experts AI, a marketplace where attorneys and litigation teams find and retain expert witnesses. Use Get Matched to request a match, or browse expert profiles to look through professional profiles yourself.