Quick answer
A plea is a defendant's formal response to a criminal charge, entered in court. A guilty plea admits the charged conduct. A not guilty plea disputes the charges and sends the case toward trial. A no contest plea does not admit the facts but accepts sentencing, and its effect on a conviction depends on the jurisdiction. Court acceptance rules and plea effects vary by jurisdiction.
What is a plea in a criminal case?
A plea is the defendant's formal response to a criminal charge, entered in court at arraignment or at a later hearing, as the court's procedure permits. The plea shapes what happens next: a trial, a plea agreement or sentencing.
What are the three types of pleas?
The three types are guilty, not guilty and no contest (nolo contendere).
What does a guilty plea mean?
A guilty plea admits the conduct described in the charge. Under Federal Rule 11(b)(3), the court must determine that there is a factual basis for the plea before entering judgment on it.
Whether to plead guilty is usually decided with a defense attorney, who reviews the evidence, including any inculpatory evidence.
What does a not guilty plea mean?
A not guilty plea disputes the charges, so the case moves toward pretrial steps or trial. It is a procedural position, not a finding of innocence.
What does a no contest plea (nolo contendere) mean?
A no contest plea means the defendant does not admit the facts but accepts sentencing. Under Federal Rule of Evidence 410(a)(2), evidence of a nolo contendere plea is not admissible against the defendant who made it, in a civil or criminal case.
How does a court accept a plea?
A court addresses the defendant personally in open court before it accepts a guilty or no contest plea. Under Rule 11, the court must inform the defendant of certain matters and determine that the defendant understands them. It must also determine that the plea is voluntary and did not result from force, threats or promises, other than promises in a plea agreement.
For a guilty plea, the court must find a factual basis before entering judgment. As the Rule 11 committee note explains, the inquiry may be made of the defendant, of the attorneys for the government and the defense, or of the presentence report; the evidence types in legal contexts that bear on it are covered separately. These are federal requirements. State courts follow their own rules.
When can a defendant withdraw a plea?
Withdrawal is governed by the rules of the court where the plea was entered, and those standards vary. Hawaii's plea statute is one example. Under HRS § 853-2, a motion made before sentence can lead the court to allow withdrawal of a guilty or no contest plea only for good cause.
How does a plea bargain relate to a plea?
A plea bargain is a negotiated agreement between the prosecution and the defense. It does not replace the plea. The defendant still enters a plea, and the court's own procedure governs whether it accepts the agreement and the plea.
Statements made in plea discussions with the prosecutor are treated separately. Under Rule 410(a)(4), such a statement is not admissible against the defendant if the discussions did not result in a guilty plea, or if they resulted in a guilty plea that was later withdrawn.
How do the consequences differ by plea type?
Rule 410 is the clearest federal rule here. It applies in civil and criminal cases, and the table below shows its effect on each plea type.
| Plea type | Trial rights | Appeal effect | Civil use under Rule 410 | Sentencing effect |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Guilty, accepted and not withdrawn | Depends on the jurisdiction | Depends on the jurisdiction | Not listed in Rule 410(a) | Depends on the jurisdiction |
| Guilty, later withdrawn | Depends on the jurisdiction | Depends on the jurisdiction | Not admissible against the defendant (Rule 410(a)(1)) | Depends on the jurisdiction |
| No contest | Depends on the jurisdiction | Depends on the jurisdiction | Not admissible against the defendant (Rule 410(a)(2)) | Depends on the jurisdiction |
| Not guilty | Case moves toward pretrial steps or trial | Depends on the jurisdiction | Rule 410 does not address it | Depends on the jurisdiction |
How do federal and state plea rules differ?
Federal courts follow the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, including Rule 11. The current federal rules are published on the uscourts.gov current rules page. State courts follow their own criminal procedure rules and statutes, which can set different standards.
Common questions about plea types and court effects
Is a no contest plea the same as a guilty plea?
No. A guilty plea admits the charged conduct. A no contest plea does not admit the facts, and the next answer covers how Rule 410 limits its later use.
Can a no contest plea be used against a defendant in a later civil lawsuit?
Not under the federal evidence rule. Federal Rule of Evidence 410(a)(2) makes a no contest plea inadmissible against the defendant who made it, in a civil or criminal case. Whether a state court applies the same limit depends on its own evidence rules.
Can a defendant withdraw a guilty plea after sentencing?
It depends on the jurisdiction. Each court's rules and statutes set the standard for withdrawing a plea, so ask counsel which standard applies to a request made after sentencing.
Does a plea always mean the case ends without a trial?
No. A not guilty plea sends the case toward trial. Even a guilty or no contest plea depends on the court accepting it: the Rule 11 committee note says a judge may reject a no contest plea and require a guilty or not guilty plea.
Are plea rules the same in every state?
No. Federal courts follow Rule 11 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure. State courts follow their own criminal procedure rules and statutes, which can set different standards. Hawaii's plea statute, for example, allows withdrawal of a guilty or no contest plea before sentence only for good cause.
When do attorneys bring in outside experts on a criminal case?
Attorneys and litigation teams bring in expert witnesses when a case needs specialist testimony or analysis. Legal Experts AI is a marketplace where attorneys and litigation teams find and retain expert witnesses, with expert profile search and AI-assisted matching. To be matched with an expert witness, use Get Matched. To review candidates yourself, browse expert profiles.




