Motion to Dismiss | Definition and Legal Process

Legal Experts AI
Motion to Dismiss | Definition and Legal Process

Quick answer

A motion to dismiss is a written request asking a court to end a case or specific claims before discovery or trial, because the pleading is legally or procedurally insufficient or the court lacks authority to hear the matter. The defendant usually files it before answering, and a plaintiff may also move to dismiss a counterclaim. The court generally decides it on the pleadings, not on evidence, with narrow exceptions. Whether a dismissal is with or without prejudice depends on the ground, the court and the jurisdiction.

This article covers federal procedure under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and gives a short note on California and New York.

How does a motion to dismiss differ from summary judgment?

A motion to dismiss tests the pleading or the court's authority, while summary judgment tests the evidence.

Motion to dismissSummary judgment
Typical timingBefore pleading, when a responsive pleading is allowedLater, after the factual record develops
What the court reviewsThe complaint and the pleadingsEvidence in the record
Evidence allowedGenerally not; outside material can convert the motionYes, the evidence is the basis of the motion
StandardWhether the pleading states a claim or the court has jurisdictionWhether a genuine dispute of material fact remains
Typical purposeEnd a claim on legal or procedural groundsEnd a claim where the facts are not in dispute

Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(d), if matters outside the pleadings are presented and not excluded on a Rule 12(b)(6) or 12(c) motion, the court must treat the motion as one for summary judgment, and every party must get a reasonable chance to present pertinent material. For the full process, see summary judgment definition and process.

Which grounds can a federal court accept for dismissal?

Rule 12(b) lists seven defenses a party may assert by motion: lack of subject-matter jurisdiction, lack of personal jurisdiction, improper venue, insufficient process, insufficient service of process, failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted, and failure to join a party under Rule 19. Statute of limitations is not on that list.

Are claim preclusion and issue preclusion the same?

No. Claim preclusion (res judicata) and issue preclusion (collateral estoppel) are separate doctrines that can limit relitigation after an earlier case. Their requirements depend on the jurisdiction, so check the rules that govern the court where the earlier case was decided.

How are arbitration disputes raised?

Arbitration is not one of the Rule 12(b) grounds. Under 9 U.S.C. § 3, a court where a suit is pending on an issue referable to arbitration under a written agreement must stay the trial, on a party's application, until arbitration has been had, if the applicant is not in default in proceeding with arbitration. Under 9 U.S.C. § 4, a party aggrieved by another's failure to arbitrate may petition a federal district court for an order directing arbitration. If the making of the agreement is in issue, the court tries that issue summarily, and a party alleged to be in default may demand a jury trial of it, outside admiralty.

When must a federal motion to dismiss be filed?

Before pleading, when a responsive pleading is allowed. Some defenses are lost if left out. Under Rule 12(h)(1), a party waives the personal jurisdiction, venue, insufficient process and insufficient service defenses if it omits them from an earlier Rule 12 motion or its responsive pleading. Failure to state a claim, failure to join a required party, and failure to state a legal defense can be raised later, in a pleading, by a Rule 12(c) motion or at trial (Rule 12(h)(2)). Subject-matter jurisdiction is different: the court must dismiss at any time it finds that it lacks it (Rule 12(h)(3)).

Can a dismissal be with or without prejudice?

Yes, depending on the ground, the order and the jurisdiction. Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 41(b), unless the dismissal order states otherwise, a dismissal operates as an adjudication on the merits, except one for lack of jurisdiction, improper venue or failure to join a party under Rule 19. A plaintiff's voluntary dismissal is without prejudice unless the notice or stipulation states otherwise, but a second dismissal of the same claim operates as an adjudication on the merits (Rule 41(a)(1)(B)). How that result limits a later suit depends on the jurisdiction's preclusion rules.

Do California and New York follow the federal rules?

Not necessarily. The federal rules above govern federal civil actions. State courts apply their own codes, which may name pre-answer challenges differently and set different deadlines and standards. Check the current state code and local court rules before relying on any motion name, deadline or standard in a California or New York case.

What happens after filing and if the motion is denied?

Filing changes the answer deadline. Under Rule 12(a)(4), serving the motion alters the time to respond unless the court sets a different time. If the court denies the motion or postpones its decision until trial, the responsive pleading must be served within 14 days after notice of the court's action. Under Rule 12(i), if a party moves, Rule 12 defenses must be heard and decided before trial unless the court orders a deferral. Whether that requires an oral hearing depends on the court and its local rules. Whether a plaintiff may amend after a grant depends on the order and the court's rules.

Frequently asked questions

Can a plaintiff file a motion to dismiss a counterclaim?

Rule 12(b) refers to "a party," so its text does not limit the motion to defendants. Whether a challenge to a counterclaim succeeds depends on the claim and the court.

Does filing a motion to dismiss delay the deadline to answer?

Yes, in federal court. Under Rule 12(a)(4), serving the motion changes the answer period unless the court sets a different time, and a denial sets a deadline of 14 days after notice of the ruling.

Can a court consider evidence when deciding a motion to dismiss?

Generally not. If outside matters are presented and the court does not exclude them, a Rule 12(b)(6) or 12(c) motion must be treated as a motion for summary judgment under Rule 12(d).

What is the difference between a demurrer and a motion to dismiss?

A demurrer is a pleading challenge used in some state courts. It is not part of the federal rules quoted here, and whether it applies depends on the state's code.

Can a case dismissed without prejudice be refiled?

Sometimes, depending on the order's wording and the ground. Under Rule 41(b), a dismissal generally operates as an adjudication on the merits unless the order states otherwise, with exceptions for lack of jurisdiction, improper venue and failure to join a party.

What is the difference between a motion to dismiss and a motion to strike?

A motion to dismiss asks the court to end a claim on a Rule 12(b) defense. A motion to strike under Rule 12(f) asks the court to remove an insufficient defense or redundant, immaterial, impertinent or scandalous matter from a pleading.

Does a motion to dismiss always require a hearing?

Not necessarily. Under Rule 12(i), if a party moves, the Rule 12 defenses must be heard and decided before trial unless the court defers them. Whether that means an oral hearing depends on the court and its local rules.

Do expert witnesses matter in a motion to dismiss?

Rarely, at this stage, because the court generally decides a Rule 12(b)(6) motion on the pleadings, but expert witnesses can matter later in the case. Legal Experts AI is a marketplace where attorneys and litigation teams find and retain expert witnesses. Teams can get matched with an expert witness through AI-assisted matching or browse expert witness profiles. For the role experts play, read expert witness roles and duties.