Quick answer
An acquittal is a formal finding that the prosecution did not prove the defendant guilty beyond a reasonable doubt, so the defendant is not convicted of that charge. It is not a finding of actual innocence. Procedures and related rules vary by U.S. jurisdiction, and the specific rules are set out below.
- Definition: In U.S. criminal law, an acquittal is the result on a charge when the prosecution has not proved guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
- Not innocence: An acquittal does not establish that the defendant is innocent.
- Not a conviction: The defendant is not convicted of that charge. Retrial and appeal limits are covered below.
What does an acquittal mean in U.S. criminal law?
An acquittal is the result when the prosecution fails to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, the standard that sits at the center of criminal trials. In In re Winship, 397 U.S. 358 (1970), the Supreme Court noted that it "has long been assumed that proof of a criminal charge beyond a reasonable doubt is constitutionally required."
The court then records the result as a formal judgment. In Fong Foo v. United States, 369 U.S. 141 (1962), the trial judge directed the jury to return verdicts of acquittal, and "a formal judgment of acquittal was subsequently entered."
Does an acquittal mean the defendant is innocent?
No. An acquittal means the prosecution did not prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. It does not establish that the defendant is innocent, because the question decided is whether the proof met the standard, not what the defendant actually did.
Civil proceedings are separate from the criminal charge. Whether a civil claim can follow an acquittal depends on the jurisdiction and the claim, so that question belongs to an attorney.
How does a judgment of acquittal differ from a directed verdict?
A judgment of acquittal is the court's formal order entering the acquittal. A directed verdict is the judge's direction to the jury to return a verdict of acquittal. Both can happen before the jury decides: in Fong Foo, the judge gave that direction while a government witness was still testifying.
In Burks v. United States, 437 U.S. 1 (1978), the trial court denied a motion for acquittal before the case was submitted to the jury. Burks notes that a defendant may file a post-trial motion for judgment of acquittal under Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 29(c). The U.S. Courts website publishes the federal rules.
State courts may use different terms for these steps, so check the terminology used in the court where the case is pending.
How does an acquittal differ from a dismissal?
An acquittal is a result on the evidence at trial. A dismissal ends a case or charge without that result, and it can happen at different stages. The grounds and timing for a dismissal depend on the jurisdiction, so check the rules of the court where the case is pending before treating a case as either one.
Can the prosecution appeal an acquittal or retry the defendant?
Under Burks, retrial is barred once a reviewing court has found the evidence insufficient to sustain the jury's verdict of guilty. Whether the prosecution can appeal an acquittal depends on the jurisdiction and its rules. The Fifth Amendment Double Jeopardy Clause is the source of that protection, as Fong Foo and Burks both describe. Fong Foo involved a federal jury trial in which the district judge directed verdicts of acquittal after seven days of trial, and a formal judgment of acquittal was subsequently entered. In Burks, the Court held that the Double Jeopardy Clause "precludes a second trial once the reviewing court has found the evidence insufficient to sustain the jury's verdict of guilty."
These cases concern retrial. They do not decide whether a prosecutor may appeal an acquittal. That depends on the jurisdiction and its rules, and other retrial and appeal situations depend on the jurisdiction and the proceeding.
What happens to the record after an acquittal?
Whether an acquittal leaves an arrest or court record public, or allows it to be sealed or expunged, depends on the jurisdiction. To find the rule that applies, ask the court clerk in the jurisdiction where the case was heard or consult an attorney there.
What should a defendant do after an acquittal?
Start by getting a certified copy of the order or judgment of acquittal, then check the records and any sealing options.
- Get a certified copy of the order or judgment of acquittal from the court that entered it.
- Check the court records for the case and for any related matter.
- Ask whether sealing or expungement is available, which process applies, and whether a deadline applies in that jurisdiction.
- Speak with a licensed attorney in the relevant jurisdiction about your own circumstances, including any civil claims.
Frequently asked questions about acquittals
Is an acquittal the same as being found not guilty?
Close to it. An acquittal is a formal finding that the prosecution did not prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, so the defendant is not convicted.
Does an acquittal lead to a sentence?
An acquittal means the defendant is not convicted of that charge. Whether any sentence follows in a case with other charges depends on the outcome of those charges.
Does an acquittal mean the defendant is innocent?
No. An acquittal means the prosecution did not prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, not that innocence was established.
Can a defendant be retried after an acquittal?
Under Burks, the Double Jeopardy Clause precludes a second trial once a reviewing court has found the evidence insufficient to sustain the jury's verdict of guilty. Whether retrial is allowed in other situations depends on the jurisdiction and the proceeding.
Can the prosecution appeal an acquittal?
No single answer applies, because whether the prosecution can appeal depends on the jurisdiction and its rules. The Supreme Court cases on retrial do not decide that question.
Does an acquittal remove an arrest or court record?
Not necessarily: whether an acquittal removes an arrest or court record depends on the jurisdiction. Ask the court clerk in the jurisdiction where the case was heard.
How do expert witnesses bear on reasonable doubt in criminal cases?
Expert witnesses can test forensic or technical evidence that bears on whether the prosecution has proved guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, and attorneys and litigation teams on either side may retain them. Legal Experts AI is a U.S.-focused online marketplace where attorneys and litigation teams find and retain expert witnesses. Users can browse expert profiles or get matched by AI.
To start, get matched with expert witnesses, or browse expert profiles to compare candidates for your matter.




